Romancing
the Threshold
Meeting change with the curiosity of lovers
Romance novels are a collective dream of union in a divided world, and they are worth our attention.
In a world that keeps feeding us dystopias and stories flattened by fear, millions of us keep reaching for romance novels. The dream these novels carry is not a wish.
It is a rehearsal for coming together and for being changed along the way, with the happy ending as its compass.
That rehearsal is personal, too. Romance novels help us romance the threshold: to meet the changes in our own lives the way lovers meet, with curiosity instead of dread.
In conversations with people who know these stories from the inside, and in episodes of my own, I ask what romance novels are stirring in us, personally and collectively.
The Liminal: Crossing the Threshold into Unfamiliar Terrain
Who am I if I don’t do what I used to do? That question has been keeping me company in the small hours, so I gave it a whole episode. It’s just me this time, talking from the middle of my own crossing about the liminal, the unfamiliar ground where the identity that got us here starts to come off.
Along the way, I stand in front of the Bayeux Tapestry, whose story stops at the battle as if nothing came after. But so much comes after: the body and mind slowly learning to keep the same time, and the kind of heartbreak that cracks us open so more can fit in. That’s the ground I’ll be teaching this December in The Liminal, a three-part series for anyone standing on it.
Grumpy Sunshine: My Husband on Romance
Almost two years of romance novels will change a house. Just ask my husband. Jason names the tropes when we watch TV now, and he says the books have made it easier to bring up the things that might be “a little touchy or edgy.”
Once a season he joins me on the show, and this time he came with opinions, including what kind of DJ Mr. Darcy would be. The one thing we didn’t settle is which of us is the grump. That part is up to you.
Kelly Jarvis: Beauty and the Beast as an Economic Story
Kelly Jarvis teaches fairy tales and folklore, and she wrote a Beauty and the Beast retelling of her own. She is also the first guest to come back to this podcast threshold. We went looking for what the romance novel took from the old tales, and came back with more than I went in for.
We explored how Beauty and the Beast can be seen as a story about money. There is a difference between the kind of wealth that hoards and the kind that circulates, and the old tales knew it long before we did. And there is a category of fairy tale, thousands of years old, in which the woman is always the one who goes out after what she has lost. Hold that next to almost any romance novel you have read.
Romance Book Club Roundtable: A Happily Ever After Every Day
Ask a romance reader what the books do for her and the first word is escape. Stay in the conversation a little longer and something else shows up. A sentence she can finally say out loud. A fight a couple stopped having. A body she came back to.
Three readers from the romance book club at Sherwood Bookstore join me for a roundtable on how romance arrived at the hardest crossings of their lives, what these books do to a woman's relationship with her own body, the trope everyone wants retired that turned out to be the best teacher in the room, and the happy ending that doesn't wait for the last page.
Christa Lewis: The Body Behind the Voice
Somewhere in North Carolina there is a padded room the size of a closet, and a woman goes into it alone and talks for three hours so that you can have one. That's the ratio. Every hour you listen to has been worked three or four times over by a body you will never meet, and by the time it reaches you all of that has been sanded off.
Christa Lewis has spent thirty years with the voice. In this conversation she takes apart what actually happens between a page and your ear: how she builds a character from the clues in the text, what the small space between the upper lip and the nose has to do with clamped-down emotion, and the thing she deliberately holds back from every listener, on purpose.
The Threshold Lover: The Eight Companions Hiding in Your TBR
Romance novels are medicine for the crossing. Not a distraction from your life changing. Medicine for it.
Season two of Romancing the Threshold opens on its own, with the idea the rest of it stands on. When a crossing is real, the thing that's missing is almost never information. Most of us know exactly what we should do, and we sit in the chair another year anyway, fully informed and completely immobile. What's missing is appetite. And appetite is what this genre keeps handing back.
In this episode: the dream that moved me to Portland and taught me to follow an image long before I understand it. A stretch of depletion, and why romance was the only thing I could keep down. What Eros actually means, and why it goes quiet years before anything collapses. What the happily ever after is doing for the psyche, and why it's a matter of justice as much as feeling. Why "guilty pleasure" was never about the books. Where the eight Threshold Lovers came from. And the eight themselves, in the four pairs they arrive in.
The Books That Read You Back
Rebecca Nelson spends her days surrounded by books, first as a bookseller helping run a romance book club, and now as a graduate student studying literature. In this conversation, she talks about the novels that unsettle her, the ones that comfort her, and the moment she realized her own life had started to read like one.
What began as a conversation about reading turned into something else entirely: a woman thinking out loud about the doors she'd quietly closed on herself, and finding, mid-sentence, that she was ready to open them again.
Kelly Jarvis on the Power of the Small
Writer and fairy tale scholar Kelly Jarvis joins Vanessa for a conversation about Beauty and the Beast, the tale at the heart of her debut novel, and why this one story keeps returning to us across centuries.
They talk about fairy tales as something far richer than children's fare, the small everyday magic that does the deepest work, the way a reader brings half a book to life herself, and why a real love story is built more from choice than from fate.
Kelly's debut novel, Sea and Stars, is a gothic Beauty and the Beast retelling set between the wild Isle of Skye and the old whaling town of Mystic, Connecticut. It comes out July 7th.
Karla Sorensen on the Why of Characters, Writing Craft, and the Body of the Writer
In this episode of Romancing the Threshold, I sit down with romance author Karla Sorensen, whose contemporary and sports romance novels (Lessons in Heartbreak, Best Laid Plans, The Best of All, among many others) I came across sideways and have been thinking about ever since. We talk about how characters arrive in a writer's imagination, the craft of bringing them onto the page, and the wrestling Karla does with a story until something cracks open.
It's a generous conversation about writing process, the inner life of characters, and the body of the writer at work. Karla writes from somewhere real, and that's what gives her stories their depth. What lives in a writer becomes what lives on the page.
Your Body Is Reading the Book Too
Romance reading isn't just for the mind. The body of the reader is the third character in every novel we open — the one nobody talks about, the one where the story actually lands. In this episode, somatic experiencing practitioner Alan Massetti and Vanessa explore what that means in practice: why arousal isn't just sexual but nervous system activation, why a scene from weeks ago can still be living in your body, why the reading slump might be your body asking for time to digest, and what it means to metabolize what we read rather than simply consume it. This is reading as embodied medicine.
Which Doors is Yours?
There are five aspects of the self that culture teaches women to hide, and romance novels have been quietly reopening every single one. In this solo episode, I name them: body, rage, pleasure, instinct, and sovereignty. Five Forbidden Doors, each one guarded by the stories we've been told to dismiss as fluff.
Drawing on my depth psychology background, my own cave year of reading 131 romance novels, and responses from real romance readers, I walk you up to each door — just enough to see which one has your name on it. Why do we keep reaching for certain tropes? What does our reading hunger know about us that we haven't named yet? And what happens when we start reading our bookshelves as maps rather than guilty pleasures?
Your Bookshelf Is Your Grimoire
Almost twenty years ago, a dream about a wedding made me abandon my thesis on Saturn and depression, and write instead about the healing power of romantic comedies. That thesis became a spell I lived: ritual, artwork, dreams, and meeting my husband more than a year later. Then I forgot about it for nearly two decades. Until my mother died, and 131 romance novels brought it all back.
In this solo episode, I share the origin story of my work with romance as medicine. How the thesis returned in a deeper form during a cave year of grief, and what I discovered about how we read. I introduce three levels of reading: the surface pleasure, the personal psychology stirring underneath, and something I can only call the collective dream. And I give you a practice: three questions you can ask tonight about whatever book is on your nightstand that will change your relationship with your reading life.
Your bookshelf isn't a guilty pleasure. It might be the most honest map you have.
Listen to the full episode and try the three-question practice. And if this resonates, explore Forbidden Doors — a six-week romance-as-medicine intensive starting May 16.
Sharon Lynn Fisher: Small Magic, Ancient Power
What if the stories we call cozy are doing something far more powerful than we think? In this conversation, gothic romance author Sharon Lynn Fisher and I explore what curiosity actually does when it meets inherited darkness — and why the small, domestic, embodied magic in her novels might be the very thing these times are asking for.
Sharon's heroines don't break curses through epic power. They make tea. They read the leaves. They ask the question no one wants asked. And through these persistent, quiet acts, something ancient and poisonous begins to transform. We talk about what gets inherited and what gets healed, why she spent years devaluing the very thing that lit her up, and what her readers keep teaching her about the value of stories the world dismisses as fluff.
Cassie Alexander: Getting Curious with the Monster
What do you do when the monster shows up and everyone around you is either terrified or worshipping it?
Romance author and nurse Cassie Alexander chose a third way: curiosity. In this conversation, we explore what it means to approach AI — the most contested threshold of our moment — with a relational stance instead of fear or adoration. We talk about writing, creativity, consciousness, and what working with AI reveals about how you actually think.
And we sit with the question underneath all of it: if AI is the new monster, what might it be seeing about us?
When the world gets strange, desire becomes our compass
This episode with author Layla Fae begins with the strangeness of our current moment — AI accelerating, the world destabilizing — but quickly widens into a conversation about creativity, desire, and the stories that shape us. Layla’s books were a lifeline during my cave year, not because of their plots, but because of what they stirred: the archetypal, the imaginative, the parts of us that remember how to navigate change. Together we explore how stories become portals, how desire becomes a compass when the world gets strange, and how women are using romance as a modern mythos for sovereignty and becoming.
Weaving the WYRD While Empires White-Knuckle Death
While empires white-knuckle their dying world, we're midwifing what's being born through every story we love. From childhood under Brazilian dictatorship to wrestling with grief through ancient myth, I explore how we're already part of the WYRD network—everyone who's ever let a story rearrange their molecules. This episode reveals why your 'guilty pleasure' stories might be exactly the medicine needed for these times, and how imagination itself is both battleground and birthing ground for what comes next.
Having your VISA Declined at the Threshold
In this intimate conversation with Jessiemarie Duplessis, we explore how adult retail spaces—stripped of sexiness and bathed in fluorescent light—become unexpected confessionals for our deepest vulnerabilities. Drawing from her experience as an accidental threshold guide, Jessiemarie reveals the universal pattern of trying to purchase our way through transformation, whether that's seeking the perfect toy to "fix" our bodies or any quick solution to bypass the patient work of change. We discuss how asking better questions becomes the foreplay for crossing any threshold, why changing doesn't mean malfunctioning, and what happens when your VISA gets declined at the crossing that only accepts vulnerability as currency. This episode invites anyone who's ever clutched their metaphorical credit card at life's edges, hoping to buy their way past becoming who they're meant to be.
Breaking the Spell of Separation: A Celtic Shaman's Guide to Romancing Uncertainty
Celtic shaman Jane Burns reveals a revolutionary understanding of spiritual reciprocity: ancestors depend on living descendants to heal what they couldn't complete in life, helping spirits seek partnership not worship, and both worlds have genuine stakes in our collective evolution. Drawing from ancient Celtic wisdom, she illuminates how threshold spaces—those uncomfortable in-between moments we typically rush through—are actually portals where magic pools and transformation becomes possible. Most profound is her teaching that we exist in permanent threshold, constantly suspended between potential and fear, which is why the Celts deliberately courted liminal moments: standing with one foot in water and one on shore, celebrating twilight as powerfully as dawn, knowing that transformation is always a collaborative dance between worlds, never a solo battle.
The Bestiary of Unearthing
A solo episode closing out a transformative year. After cataloging 50 monsters across 125 romance novels, seven creatures emerged as threshold guides through grief and reclamation. These aren't just steamy reads but medicine for anyone exhausted from being the emotional regulator, the perpetually useful one. At its heart: the Beauty and the Beast truth that we need witnessing without performance—monsters who see us whole without needing our usefulness as currency. An invitation to recognize the guides waiting in your own threshold seasons.
What Story Are You Telling at the Threshold?
Rune reader and elder Ingrid Kincaid explores how every threshold demands sacrifice and why the stories we tell about change shape our experience of it. We discuss the gift of the liminal space, why resistance to change closes our curiosity, and why we need elders to step forward (not aside) to translate ancient wisdom for modern crossings. For anyone wanting to meet life's transitions as sacred exchanges rather than obstacles to overcome.